Surgical Patients Not Getting Information on Alternatives

It’s awfully hard for patients to participate in decisions about their medical care if they don’t know all their options.

But that’s exactly what seems to be happening, at least with many Medicare patients who received a stent procedure for coronary disease or prostate surgery for cancer, according to a new study.

The research, published online by the Journal of General Internal Medicine, surveyed 685 patients who had prostate-cancer surgery and 472 who had stents for coronary disease about their decision-making process.

While those conditions are “clinically really different, the thing that intrigued us was that completely conservative treatment is a reasonable option for both,” says Floyd J. Fowler Jr., an author of the study and senior research fellow at the Center for Survey Research at the University of Massachusetts Boston. (There’s been growing concern in the last several years that stents are overused, as the WSJ has reported.)

Yet only 10% of the stent patients surveyed recalled discussing an alternative to stenting as a serious option. Prostate-surgery patients had a different experience; 64% recalled discussing alternatives to surgery.

“We’re not saying that they made the wrong choice” by having the surgery or stenting, but “people should know what all the options are,” says Fowler, who is also senior scientific advisor at the Informed medical Decisions Foundation.

Only 19% of stent recipients recalled discussing the cons of the procedure, while 63% of the prostate-surgery patients reported the same. And only 16% of stent recipients recalled being asked their preferences for treatment type, vs. 76% of prostate-surgery patients…

Read the complete article @ WSJ Health Blog.

Articles on Dr. Massen's Reading List reflect the original author's views, which Dr. Massen may or may not agree with. No information or opinions provided here should be used for the purpose of self-diagnosis or as a substitute for medical advice by a physician licenced in your state. Always consult your family doctor before beginning any new treatment, changing your diet, starting a new exercise regimen. If you live in the East Bay, feel free to call our Hayward office for health consultation by Dr. Massen.